Dune Encyclopedia discussion Tor.COM

[Robspierre]

http://www.tor.com/blogs/2010/09/out-of ... e#comments

Someone has posted a link to googledocs where the Dune Encyclopedia has been posted. So far all the comments are saying the only real Dune are Frank's six original works.

Rob

[inhuien]

So far all the comments are saying the only real Dune are Frank's six original works.

As is only correct, here's the link to the google doc thingamajig.

http://docs.google.com/viewer?url=http: ... .pdf&pli=1

See where they're getting it from.

[lotek]

left my contribution

EDIT
ow yeah awaiting moderation(I hope calling the two tossers "the dumbasses of Dune" is seen as the friendly banter it really is... not!)

[TheDukester]

Great find there, both for the DE itself and the discussion that follows. Has anyone seen a pro-KJA comment? I scanned through pretty quickly, but all I saw was love for the DE and loathing for Spanky McDune.

My favorite: the guy mentioning his letter to TheKeith begging him to stop writing McDunes. A direct contradiction of Keith's oft-told "we got thousands of positive letters" tale.

[merkin muffley]

I think anybody with sense can tell the difference between Dune and McDune.

[JustSomeGuy]

¡Thank you, inhuien, for the link!

I had heard of this encyclopedia, but had never gotten a look at it. Must say I'm enjoying it so far.

[lotek]

I think anybody with sense

of smell

can tell the difference between Dune and McDune.

thanks for setting that one up !!

[merkin muffley]

You're welcome, Lotek.

[inhuien]

JustSomeGuy, .