DUNE DISCUSSION FORUM FOR ORTHODOX HERBERTARIANS
http://www.jacurutu.com/
Yes, it is the Sietch's water now. My water shall mingle with your water.SandChigger wrote:Achlan wasachlan! Ma-ka hiya ma-na! Welcome, doubly welcome! Your water is our water!
Visigoth wrote: BTW...isn't this tribe supposed to be the bad guys in Dune?
The Cast Out?
Keep digging in the older threads.Visigoth wrote:BTW...isn't this tribe supposed to be the bad guys in Dune?
The Cast Out?
Would anyone not familiar with that drama, or those who've just read the first book know anything about that though?Freakzilla wrote:I started this forum with the very generous help of Omphalos and Ragabash after I and others were banned from the official dunenovels forum (and arrakeen).
So, I thought the name was obvious.
Nope. But he said he'd read Dune and CoD.Nekhrun wrote:Would anyone not familiar with that drama, or those who've just read the first book know anything about that though?Freakzilla wrote:I started this forum with the very generous help of Omphalos and Ragabash after I and others were banned from the official dunenovels forum (and arrakeen).
So, I thought the name was obvious.
Visigoth wrote:A long, long, long time ago, I read Dune and Children of Dune.
I think there is a topic around here where I explained the "A" in T(A)U to Thing. That topic has it about all the forums on our wanderings to Jacurutu I think.Nekhrun wrote:Keep digging in the older threads.Visigoth wrote:BTW...isn't this tribe supposed to be the bad guys in Dune?
The Cast Out?
We should have a topic about that somewhere and maybe sticky it for new members.
Or, you could spent 5 min. on the official forum and you'd know why none of us are welcome there.
Freakzilla wrote:That's how I wrote the novel, wanting you to participate with the best of your own imagination. I did not aim for the lowest common denominator and 'write down" to anyone. You and I have a compact and my responsibility is to entertain you as richly as possible, always giving you as much extra as I can. I assume you are intelligent and will enlist your own imagination. You'll see that when you read the Dune excerpt and the other stories in this collection.
~Frank Herbert, Intro to Eye
Looking back on it, I realize I did the right thing instinctively. You don't
write for success. That takes part of your attention away from the writing. If
you're really doing it, that's all you're doing: writing.
There's an unwritten compact between you and the reader. If someone enters a
bookstore and sets down hard earned money (energy) for your book, you owe that
person some entertainment and as much more as you can give.
That was really my intention all along.
~Frank Herbert, Intro to Heretics of Dune
Who We Are
First, a little about me. I first read Dune at age thirteen in 1984, just before the David Lynch movie hit the big screen, and was immediately hooked. I caught up with the series soon afterwards and read Heretics of Dune and Chapterhouse: Dune as they were published. Then I read everything else FH wrote that I could find. I even read the entire Dune Encyclopedia complied by Dr. Willis McNelly. I was devastated when I learned of my new favorite author's death. Since then I've read the series roughly once a year,give or take. Years later came the internet and discussion forums. I lurked at Dreamers of Dune for about a year, afraid to expose my ignorance, but after building up the courage to chance participating in the discussion I found that I was gaining credibility in knowledge of the Dune series and became an active member. DoD eventually died and since then I've been a fixture in whatever Dune forum(s) was the most active, sometimes in multiple forums. Sometimes as a member, sometimes as moderator or administrator. Eventually in 1999 I was thrilled to read news that Brian Herbert and Kevin J. Anderson were planning to continue the series. I eagerly bought and read the new Dune books and was sorely disappointed to say the least. I could have tolerated the abysmal writing if the authors had bothered to pretend they understood Frank Herbert's books and remained consistent with his themes and details. I wouldn't be surprised if I found out the new authors haven't even read the originals. When the Herbert estate opened a Dune Novels bulletin board in 2006, I immediately joined and voiced my disdain, for which I was immediately banned. I emailed the administrator, Frank Herbert's grandson Byron Merritt, and upon apologizing for personally insulting the authors and promising to refrain from doing it again was allowed to rejoin the forum. There I proceeded to make 5,691 posts before eventually being banned again and am still, years after being banned, the leading poster there. I wasn't the only one banned for voicing their negative opinions of the new books, not by far. Most of the knowledgeable people I'd come to know in the Dune fan community felt the same way I did and the Dunenovels standard operating procedure for dealing with negative comments is to ban the member. Eventually this lead to only the most mindless discussion there and I saw an opportunity for a new Dune fan forum where members would not be censored. So I started Jacurutu, named after the Cast Out in Children of Dune. This leads to...
What We Stand For
First of all, this is not an anti-KJA/BH forum. This is a FH's Dune fan forum. However, current events in the world of Dune have drawn fire towards the new authors for what many fans consider raping and milking FH's legacy for profit, and that is the topic du jour. If I had my way, we'd only be discussing FH's works but one of the ideas this forum was founded on was to let the discussion take it's own course without censorship. So that is the way it goes. Contrary to what some might say, we are not against the continuation of the Dune series in any medium. We are against BADLY continuing Dune in any medium. The Herberts have hired a notorious hack to bring them a steady paycheck with a total lack of respect for the deep and serious ideas and themes present in FH's legacy and have turned it into a McDune franchise. It's a shame that none of the many qualified, GOOD authors have not had a chance to do FH's legacy justice. At least, if they aren't going to give a real author a shot, they should stop defiling Dune with the pulp space opera crap they've been churning out.
Well, that's the gist of it.
I exist only to serve,
Freakzilla
A Thing of Eternity wrote:Welcome! Some of us really are the Cast Out, banned from the official website, but many simply come here first and never post on the official site (nobody really posts there much).
Eyes High wrote:And some of were banned fro. DN simply because of our connection with Jacarutu.
She must've sent some nasty PM's or something. I can still post over there.A Thing of Eternity wrote:I forgot about you being banned without ANY reason whatsoever, just because you posted here... unreal.
They are really messed up people.
Now Nek. Would I really do that?Nekhrun wrote:She must've sent some nasty PM's or something. I can still post over there.A Thing of Eternity wrote:I forgot about you being banned without ANY reason whatsoever, just because you posted here... unreal.
They are really messed up people.
You know me better....I think.... 
SandRider wrote:...
some of us were pre-banned from the Official Corporate Dune Forum, ... and their accounts were never activated, even tho the username is still in the "memberlist" ....
Bad boys, bad boys, and girls of course, what you gonna do when they come for you...SandRider wrote:Visigoth wrote: BTW...isn't this tribe supposed to be the bad guys in Dune?
The Cast Out?
Yes.
Exactly.
and not Kosher.
. It looks you keep each other honest. I'm really sorry that it has to be either here and not necessarily there. I guess the password issue is why I see some of the same member names here and there also.
No, I slipped. the purity of Frank's works! No one has the right to steal someone elses thoughts, change them, and say they are the original thoughts. 
Jacurutu is where Leto II went to escape assassination and where Gurney and Namri administered the spice overdose to him.. So you could say it was where the GP started.Visigoth wrote:[So...you name yourselves after the bad guys, but you really are good guys defending FH's legacy. Ironic isn't it, I think. The name I mean. If I had a PDF copy of Dune, I would look for Jacurutu to find if they contributed a little bit towards the Golden Path, just like this Sietch is contributing towards the survival of the purity of FH's bodily fluids