DUNE DISCUSSION FORUM FOR ORTHODOX HERBERTARIANS
http://www.jacurutu.com/
Well put.Chilon wrote:...my interest in the DUNE universe is stronger than my passing desire for entertainment, and these works sacrifice the more important need.
Good man!Pushtrack
Ok, we're talking the newest book. Hm before I speak of PoD, I will speak of the other recent books. Heretics was ok, nothing on Franks own work. Sandworms was horrible. I read a bit of PoD and it was already coming across as worse than Sandworms which is an accomplishment, but not something I intended to endure when I have so many other books that I'd put on a higher priority.
I got PoD as a gift. Wouldn't have bought it myself after being let down by Sandworms, but I'll still give it a chance when I'm desperate enough. I love the original Dune novels, and when it comes to the BH/KJA books, the Prelude to Dune House books are quite good. Once you ignore the inconsistencies, that is.
Dune Fan Store
Well... I just think you're arrogant Pushtrak and that's all about you.
Product Description
At the end of Frank Herbert's final novel, Chapterhouse: Dune, a ship carrying a crew of refugees escapes into the uncharted galaxy, fleeing from a terrifying, mysterious Enemy. The fugitives used genetic technology to revive key figures from Dune's past--including Paul Muad'Dib and Lady Jessica--to use their special talents to meet the challenges thrown at them.
yeah thrown is the correct term in this case
Based directly on Frank Herbert's final outline, which lay hidden in two safe-deposit boxes for a decade, Sandworms of Dune will answer the urgent questions Dune fans have been debating for two decades: the origin of the Honored Matres, the tantalizing future of the planet Arrakis, the final revelation of the Kwisatz Haderach, and the resolution to the war between Man and Machine. This breathtaking new novel in Frank Herbert’s Dune series has enough surprises and plot twists to please even the most demanding reader.
PushtrackIf taking a dislike to authors defecating on a franchise I love makes it so, then colour me arrogant.
That guy's a preeq even if he doesn't know it yet!DuneFanStore
You focus on minor issues but we, the imperial sardaukar will show no mercy to one that is so critical to the greatest novel known to men.
You mean he's inconsistent?SandChigger wrote:I believe we know Pushtrak from the old Dumb Novels days.
IIRC he has alternated between the preeq & OH viewpoints.
SadisticCynic wrote:You mean he's inconsistent?SandChigger wrote:I believe we know Pushtrak from the old Dumb Novels days.
IIRC he has alternated between the preeq & OH viewpoints.
Ho-hum, and there goes the great white hope.lotek wrote:SadisticCynic wrote:You mean he's inconsistent?SandChigger wrote:I believe we know Pushtrak from the old Dumb Novels days.
IIRC he has alternated between the preeq & OH viewpoints.
I'm not willing to assume he meant to write "Franks other work".Pushtrak wrote:Heretics was ok, nothing on Franks own work.
inhuien wrote:Ho-hum, and there goes the great white hope.I'm not willing to assume he meant to write "Franks other work".Pushtrak wrote:Heretics was ok, nothing on Franks own work.
I'm not really sure what's that supposed to mean...Ok, we're talking the newest book. Hm before I speak of PoD, I will speak of the other recent books. Heretics was ok, nothing on Franks own work. Sandworms was horrible. I read a bit of PoD and it was already coming across as worse than Sandworms which is an accomplishment, but not something I intended to endure when I have so many other books that I'd put on a higher priority.
really???shadoo wrote:I have to agree, the prequels was so much garbage. I love KJA and his Saga of the Seven Suns is up there with Dune as another epic, but the writing on the prequels was so much poop. The sequels Hunters of Dune and Sandworms of Dune was more than amazing, I'm astounded at the inconsistencies. Will I read Paul of Dune and Winds of Dune, maybe, or I'll just get the new series from KJA, terra and enjoy that.
He mentions Sandworms directly after it, perhaps he meant Hunters instead of Heretics.Ok, we're talking the newest book. Hm before I speak of PoD, I will speak of the other recent books. Heretics was ok, nothing on Franks own work. Sandworms was horrible. I read a bit of PoD and it was already coming across as worse than Sandworms which is an accomplishment, but not something I intended to endure when I have so many other books that I'd put on a higher priority.
I'm thinking he meant Hunters too. It happens to me all the time, I mean to say or type "Heretics" and "Hunters" comes out. I punch myself each time it happens.SadisticCynic wrote:He mentions Sandworms directly after it, perhaps he meant Hunters instead of Heretics.Ok, we're talking the newest book. Hm before I speak of PoD, I will speak of the other recent books. Heretics was ok, nothing on Franks own work. Sandworms was horrible. I read a bit of PoD and it was already coming across as worse than Sandworms which is an accomplishment, but not something I intended to endure when I have so many other books that I'd put on a higher priority.
In Bizarro World Pushtrak wrote:KJA and his Saga of the Seven Suns is ... so much poop.
