sand dancer
Posted: 17 Aug 2009 18:46
something to whet your gristle...
DUNE DISCUSSION FORUM FOR ORTHODOX HERBERTARIANS
http://www.jacurutu.com/
if I turn round and start hurling abuse at an individual, I will get banned.Sandwurm88 wrote:Oh yeah, and get the hell off this site.
Look, the BURDEN OF PROOF is on you. NO ONE ELSE HERE remembers EVER reading about any such incident except in the McDune books. (And that wasn't Chapter House Planet but Wallach IX.) POST A QUOTE PROVING WHAT YOU CLAIM OR SHUT UP ABOUT IT.semuta wrote:Chig, there is a scene in one of the later 2 books where a guildship crashes on chapterhouse, you should read them again, its in there. Its not me who has been confused by the prequels & sequels. I remain pure dune.
No more pathetic than a no-talent, dole-sponging loser who has to sneak back onto websites where he is known for a nut case under a plethora of different user names, just to post more wingnut crap that NO ONE ELSE WITH A BRAIN has ever demonstrated an interest in. Obviously you "evolved beings" vibratoring on higher frequency planes have no problem with blatant deception.semuta wrote:I dont know where people get off on acting like that, insulting people on websites, its pathetic lol
"Victory for ZIM!!!"Sandwurm88 wrote:I keep on thinking your name is Semen.
Is Hyppo back?SandChigger wrote:No more pathetic than a no-talent, dole-sponging loser who has to sneak back onto websites where he is known for a nut case under a plethora of different user names, just to post more wingnut crap that NO ONE ELSE WITH A BRAIN has ever demonstrated an interest in.
semuta wrote:OK omphalos I will limit it to a few things a week, and consider myself censored, although another admin at this forum has told me it is uncensored.
Chig, there is a scene in one of the later 2 books where a guildship crashes on chapterhouse, you should read them again, its in there. Its not me who has been confused by the prequels & sequels. I remain pure dune.
Drunken Idaho wrote:That seriously never happened...semuta wrote:Chig, there is a scene in one of the later 2 books where a guildship crashes on chapterhouse, you should read them again, its in there. Its not me who has been confused by the prequels & sequels. I remain pure dune.
And just to entertain that notion for a moment, Semuta, what was the outcome of the guildship crash situation? What purpose did it serve in the overall story?
Is he, really?A Thing of Eternity wrote:He's gone.
SandChigger wrote:Drunken Idaho wrote:That seriously never happened...semuta wrote:Chig, there is a scene in one of the later 2 books where a guildship crashes on chapterhouse, you should read them again, its in there. Its not me who has been confused by the prequels & sequels. I remain pure dune.
And just to entertain that notion for a moment, Semuta, what was the outcome of the guildship crash situation? What purpose did it serve in the overall story?Is he, really?A Thing of Eternity wrote:He's gone.
No point in pointing out it never happened, DI; he's made up his mind it did, so....
Dont tell me this is the first you've heard of that!Drunken Idaho wrote:A pre-Tyrant no-ship?!
That's BULLSHIT.
Yep. Crashed it into an apple orchard and ended up in a creek.Freakzilla wrote:Didn't Rabban crash the pre-tyrant harkonnen no-ship on Wallach IX?
I must have blocked out the House Corrino one... that's just wrong.SandChigger wrote:Yep. Crashed it into an apple orchard and ended up in a creek.Freakzilla wrote:Didn't Rabban crash the pre-tyrant harkonnen no-ship on Wallach IX?
And there is a Heighliner in House Corrino that emerges from foldspace too close to the planet (due to "Navigator error") and crashes into it.
Either one could be what smooty was raving about.
I do believe it is... Didn't Hadi Benotto say that Leto's dictatel chamber was the first, or one of the first no-rooms? She seemed pretty sure that even if it wasn't, it was created using the same primitive principles that led to modern no-ship technology. If those same primitive principles existed before Leto II, then why hadn't Ix perfected it by the time of GEoD? Bah, no point in pondering that any further. Another one of Keith's foolish whims.Freakzilla wrote:Dont tell me this is the first you've heard of that!Drunken Idaho wrote:A pre-Tyrant no-ship?!
That's BULLSHIT.