Jᴀᴄᴜʀᴜᴛᴜ - Tʜᴇ Cᴀsᴛ Oᴜᴛ

grandaughters make you feel funny 'bout that kinda thing .....

Another entire thread to be shook off The Dune-Sketch.
{God, I love you people...}

Over There > Paul of Dune > Errors in PoD / all today :

Nekhrun wrote:

Ksander wrote:
I was wondering, if I don't understand something or it's realy an inconsistence?

Didn't FH wright in Dune, tha space tracel to Arrakis was first travel for Paul? and Duke Leto told him about highliners etc...? But in Paul of Dune, when PAul is twelwe he travel with the parents to Ecaz?

Please, explain this one to me.

All perceived inconsistencies are now due to Irulan's influence. It is planned and no fault of the authors. That's straight from an email reply from kja.

leagued wrote:So... did Irulan write Dune or Paul of Dune? Or does she have reality-altering powers? I'm guessing she wrote Dune, because its clear to me now that what FH wrote was flawed throughout and clearly inconsistent with the canon Dune being published today.

edit to add:

Nekhrun wrote:According to kja she wrote Dune. I'm guessing he'll say she wrote Messiah and parts of Children as well, I'm guessing he'll say Harq al Ada had something to do with it as well.

and Merritt has unblocked this IP again. Or it was unblocked and I forgot. Something, I can't keep track anymore - whatever.

SandRider wrote:Another entire thread to be shook off The Dune-Sketch.
{God, I love you people...}

Over There > Paul of Dune > Errors in PoD / all today :

Nekhrun wrote:

Ksander wrote:
I was wondering, if I don't understand something or it's realy an inconsistence?

Didn't FH wright in Dune, tha space tracel to Arrakis was first travel for Paul? and Duke Leto told him about highliners etc...? But in Paul of Dune, when PAul is twelwe he travel with the parents to Ecaz?

Please, explain this one to me.

All perceived inconsistencies are now due to Irulan's influence. It is planned and no fault of the authors. That's straight from an email reply from kja.

leagued wrote:So... did Irulan write Dune or Paul of Dune? Or does she have reality-altering powers? I'm guessing she wrote Dune, because its clear to me now that what FH wrote was flawed throughout and clearly inconsistent with the canon Dune being published today.

I'd like to see him delete this one. It's straight from HLP Grand Puba: kja.

Nekhrun wrote:I'd like to see him delete this one.

I'll bet you Chigger's anal virginity you will, by tomorrow afternoon.

SandRider wrote:

Nekhrun wrote:I'd like to see him delete this one.

I'll bet you Chigger's anal virginity you will, by tomorrow afternoon.

Speaking metaphorically (doubly, I suppose) I think Chig gave me his anus a few threads ago.

I think I was talking about the new ones, after the metamorphosis.
You don't have plans for both of them do you ?
Tell you what, let me wager away one, and I'll throw in Simon's literal virginity.
Plus some pics of Mandy.
And a few links to some farm-porn Sloey sent me. (that boy's sick)
Deal ?







{in comedy circles, that's called a "call-back", I think}

SandRider wrote:I think I was talking about the new ones, after the metamorphosis.
You don't have plans for both of them do you ?
Tell you what, let me wager away one, and I'll throw in Simon's literal virginity.
Plus some pics of Mandy.
And a few links to some farm-porn Sloey sent me. (that boy's sick)
Deal ?







{in comedy circles, that's called a "call-back", I think}

sorry, no deal. It makes a pleasant sound, what with the chitin on the outside ring knocking against the quarters and a box of tic-tacs in my pocket.

Omphalos wrote:

SandRider wrote:

Nekhrun wrote:I'd like to see him delete this one.

I'll bet you Chigger's anal virginity you will, by tomorrow afternoon.

Speaking metaphorically (doubly, I suppose) I think Chig gave me his anus a few threads ago.

You at least used lube right? It's only proper to use lube, more fun for all!

Rob

Hey!

WHAT ? Easy, Slingblade ......

Over There > Paul of Dune > Errors in PoD / this morning:

Ksander wrote:But this information was written in the main text, not in the epigraphs.

I'll still give it until this afternoon when Merritt can finally get thru to Kevin and
get his instructions for the weekend activity. It looks like a new, possibly legimate
user has registered, knocking off the last new user:(screencapture yesterday)

but that user is still in the memberlist, so Merritt's just not awake yet.
There is no way he'll let that {the thread} sit there 'til Monday & take a chance on Kevin seeing it .....


{edit to add:}
Huh.

Over There > Index / 2 minutes ago

If Merritt deletes all these fake registrations, the ones that contain anti-HLP messages that is, what does that do to the registered users count ? I had thought that all the protest newusers would just bump up his count, back to the quanity=quality thing. Why he was just de-activating OH users instead of deleting them. Then I thought, well, he may just be paying some apes like Arnie with gummi-worms to change the names to something believeable. But then, if that was the plan, they could just create a bunch of sockpuppet accounts themselves. Maybe it's too early in the morning to think clearly. I just can see Merritt pointing to 1030 registered users as an indication of the success of his board. Nevermind .....

{edited for clarity - didn't do a very good job with that. sorry}

Over There > Paul of Dune > Errors in PoD // Deathwatch Continued:

Nekhrun wrote:

Ksander wrote:But this information was written in the main text, not in the epigraphs.

Not according to kja. Even the narrative text was written and influenced by Irulan. I don't know how he reconciles that with all of the internal dialogue going on in that book.

leagued wrote:Well, its clear now that anything Frank wrote was an in-universe text that should be attributed to Irulan, Harq al-Ada, Leto II's crystal scribing device, or... uh... Futars. Actually, Futars probably wrote them all, which is why they have so many glaring inconsistencies with the true Dune universe.

RazzBerry wrote:I could have sworn I posted in this thread but now it's gone. I didn't call any one names only went straight to the point and asked if Kevin J. Anderson thinks we are stupid, and if the Admin a relitive to Frank thinks that making Franks books false history is ok. Aparently by his actions he thinks it is. Would it not be better to respond to my post rather than delete it?

Nekhrun wrote:Maybe not futars, but certainly the BG at Chapterhouse. It seems a move to silence any of the critics and is a way for them to simply write whatever they want without having to worry about the inconsistencies we've been talking about for years now. Makes me wonder why they even bothered coming up with their own massive Dune concordance.

RazzBerry wrote:How could they think making Franks books error filled text books would silence the critics? By far this is the worse thing they have done. How could any one stand up and defend this? This is an open question. I would rather some one try and respond, rather than delete my post again.

Thanks for keeping this around. Razz had his question deleted before I got there, so I just went and answered it anyway.

Over There > Paul of Dune > Errors in PoD // thread now after deleted posts :

Nekhrun wrote:

Ksander wrote:But this information was written in the main text, not in the epigraphs.

Not according to kja. Even the narrative text was written and influenced by Irulan. I don't know how he reconciles that with all of the internal dialogue going on in that book.

Nekhrun wrote:I'll answer the deleted question about why they might be doing this.
There is no reason not to. Fewer critics are reading their books now, I can't even finish this one yet. You will see less and less criticism of them and the fans of them can finally read in peace, not questioning anything.

absolutely insane. why didn't he delete the entire thread ? what is the criteria for deletion now ?
and BabyMamaBoyfriend has been deleted, another "newuser" has registered, and the total count
is down to 1027. I had wanted him to just admit defeat and close down the board; now, it seems
to be too much fun. Dance, Monkey, Dance !!

{edit to add}

RazzBerry wrote:Why do I keep getting deleted, am I making too much sense? I am not being derogitory to the Author, just making a very valid point.
Won't this new revelation create more critics? It should. Thats why I think it could not be to shut them up. If it was I think it was a very poor way to do it.
Admin, Why do you not repond to what I say? Is it because you have nothing to back yourself with? All you have is a delete button. I have reason. Please show me you have the same.

fiesty !

{edit to add}
Over There > Index // just now

fantastic !
Razzberry's last post just deleted, then :

can he post faster than Merritt can delete ?
Will he just be banned right here and now ?
stay tuned !

oh shit ! TOUCHDOWN ALABAMA !!!

{edit}
Merritt deletes Razzberry's post & latest "newuser" Cowards Delete Posts ...... he logs out !! Razzberry's still on the board !! Did Merritt not realize ?? OH NO, Razzberry's off the board without posting ! .... was he banned ? Oh my goodness ! We'll have to wait for the instant replay, folks ......
But wait ! :


TOUCHDOWN LSU !!

Over There > Paul of Dune > Errors in PoD

Razzberry wrote:The admin must fear what I say as he keeps delteting my posts. The my point has gone unansweared, thefore I must conclude he has no answear. But I will keep posting in hopes that he will deem it worth his while to respond instead of trying to hide the voice of reason.

My challange to Byron is to tell me why he apreciates the fact that according the the Paul of Dune, Franks books are false history. IF you deem it nessesary to delete my post again, you will not be doing it without onlookers, those who will judge you. Show you are not afraid of what I say by responding. It takes me alot of effort to formulate my thoughts and put it on this board. You probably can tell by my sentence structure, and grammar. Surley some one like you has nothing to fear from some one like me. I believe my thoughts have value, please respond instead of hiding behind a delete button.

Timeout - LSU ...

Razzberry on DN wrote:It takes me alot of effort to formulate my thoughts and put it on this board. You probably can tell by my sentence structure, and grammar.

Hmm...can we use this in another thread here...?

Over There > Paul of Dune > Errors in PoD

Arnie, clearly in relapse wrote:I'm reading a scholarly book about Frank Herbert which may shed some light on this issue. . .

. . . In a monological design the hero is closed, and the limits of the meaning are sharply outlined. Yet Herbert has renounced all of these monological premises. . . Herbert's authorial position, then, is one that refuses to finalize "this complex mixture," as he calls it, or to assume a stance of authority understood in the monological senses that would deny the reader his freedoms in recreating the world of Dune.
~William Touponce

So it's up to the reader whether or not she/he wishes to accept any so called "changes."

Razzberry wrote:Is it your position that these are not changes? That the text of Frank's work is now viewed as less than cannon, so as to fit the new books?

2 minutes left in the 4th quarter, Alabama 21, LSU 21 ..... it's down to the wire, folks .....

{edit}

Nekhrun wrote:Got one!

Frank Herbert in Dune wrote:
I didn't even draw my knife, but it'll
be said of this day that I slew twenty Sardaukar by my own hand.

If this was really Irulan writing, why didn't she just say that he killed twenty Sardaukar?

SEC Overtime, the best kind ....

{edit} Roll Tide, 10-0 !!

Arnoloco is the bunion of Dune. I'm mildly amused by his desperation in trying to justify that SHITE pumped out of Anderson's scabby backside. It's obvious the hack has made yet another fuck up, yet Arnoloco still tries to find excuses for him. Talk about love being blind.

Poor Arnoloco, stuck on Dumbnovels with Pansyass. Much like a bloody tampon on the floor of the ladies lavatory, no one wants to go anywhere near him.

Hello, luv. Good to see you. I'm just hanging around this morning arguing with the New Guy, waiting for Merrit to wake up and start deleting these posts. Please post something funny and interesting. Please...

About what?

ummmm.. Beyonce changing her name ?
grasping at straws here ....

You've put me on the spot, I can't think of anything to say.

Is there anyone on here who you hate?