Page 2 of 2

Posted: 04 Apr 2008 08:33
by inhuien
Orald if you take that logic to it's conclusion then there would be no need for the Sisterhood to have any no-initiate staff at all.

Posted: 04 Apr 2008 09:04
by orald
Yep. Why do they keep males around? I have a guess but... :P

No, if I take anything to it's conclusion I bet I somehow end up being a Nazi, something will somehow lead to it.
The whole question is: Why is Clairby so god damned important, as a driver(ok, pilot too), that they'll make a cyborg out of him against all their beliefs?
Are they having a car race that they need him for? Is driving so difficult in the Duniverse?

And they need non-initiates/non-BG staff to bulk up their numbers.
Initiates are females only, and only ones that have been deemed good enough to perhaps become future RMs.
It's very nice to have the cream of the top, but it also means they lack such things as hordes of low key technicians, workers and even army grunts.
You don't throw a battallion made up of RMs that have been trained for years upon years and could serve at better things. For that you have poor Joe Shmoe with his knife and lasgun.

But to make a cyborg in a post BJ universe...that's very urgent indeed.

Maybe this should be transfered to the BG forum already.

Posted: 04 Apr 2008 10:00
by Freakzilla
I don't think it was against their beliefs since they were prepared to do it before the fact. It's not as if they had to research lost technology, they were ready. The BG never really subscribed to the proscriptions of the BJ.

Posted: 04 Apr 2008 12:55
by orald
then why is Odrade so reluctant to do so? Her doubts seem to indicate they're not completely removed from the BJ's effects, even on something I personally see no connection to AI like cyborgs.
It's not like they're robots with some human flesh, they're humans with artificial body parts to support them.
Though I do understand the shock it might cause, seeing a human "connected" to machine.

Posted: 04 Apr 2008 12:57
by Freakzilla
Why do they have computers?

Posted: 04 Apr 2008 13:05
by orald
Because they can't store all that info in human minds.
But Odrade's hessitation seems to indicate cyborgs are a bit of a frowned upon thing, to say the least.

Maybe she's got bad OM from the cymeks. :lol:

Posted: 04 Apr 2008 13:08
by Freakzilla
orald wrote:Because they can't store all that info in human minds.
But Odrade's hessitation seems to indicate cyborgs are a bit of a frowned upon thing, to say the least.

Maybe she's got bad OM from the cymeks. :lol:
Maybe it's because cyborgs aren't something they can hide, like a computer?

Posted: 04 Apr 2008 13:14
by orald
Hmm, yes, that and like I said previously, there's a certain frightening, creepy aspect to combining human and machine as opposed to just machine, wouldn't you agree?

Posted: 04 Apr 2008 13:17
by Freakzilla
Yes, but it's a matter of degree. When does a cyborg stop being human?

Posted: 04 Apr 2008 13:26
by orald
Unless you change his mind, never. A cymek(boo) is still a human, even retarded P&B got that.
Of course, their robots are also human, even though they're as intellegant as braindead 5 y-o's.

Posted: 17 Apr 2008 09:38
by Tleilax Master B
orald wrote:Unless you change his mind, never. A cymek(boo) is still a human, even retarded P&B got that.
Of course, their robots are also human, even though they're as intellegant as braindead 5 y-o's.
That last bit really annoys me when I read their crap. You can't tell a difference from just the dialogue between the robots and the humans. Its pretty piss poor writing with no clear distinction between character types.

Posted: 17 Apr 2008 14:02
by SandChigger
Yeah, they're supposed to be non-human and not understand humans and yet they seem (like) fairly (stupid) human(s) to me.

It's bad writing. Period.

(Brian has some pretty shitty robot characters in Timeweb, too, btw. ;) )