Jᴀᴄᴜʀᴜᴛᴜ - Tʜᴇ Cᴀsᴛ Oᴜᴛ

Freakzilla wrote:Besides, we've discussed FH's errors in great detail here (Farok had three arms).

Besides, we've discussed FH's errors in great detail here (Farok had three arms)

NotOnasander wrote:

Besides, we've discussed FH's errors in great detail here (Farok had three arms)

Kevin is a nice guy, I got to meet him in person not to long ago. It was pretty awesome. I agree, Frank made a lot of mistakes, but Brian and Kevin are going through the old novels now and correcting them, there is alot of stuff Frank didn't get about Dune, and it doesn't track very well with the majority of the books. They'll have to be changed to keep the canon non-contradicting. Out with the old in with the new.

Omphalos wrote:

NotOnasander wrote:

Besides, we've discussed FH's errors in great detail here (Farok had three arms)

Kevin is a nice guy, I got to meet him in person not to long ago. It was pretty awesome. I agree, Frank made a lot of mistakes, but Brian and Kevin are going through the old novels now and correcting them, there is alot of stuff Frank didn't get about Dune, and it doesn't track very well with the majority of the books. They'll have to be changed to keep the canon non-contradicting. Out with the old in with the new.

That was subtle.

NotOnasander wrote:Brian and Kevin are going through the old novels now and correcting them, there is alot of stuff Frank didn't get about Dune, and it doesn't track very well with the majority of the books. They'll have to be changed to keep the canon non-contradicting. Out with the old in with the new.

NotOnasander wrote:

Nekhrun wrote:

NotOnasander wrote:

lotek wrote:

I wrote:

captain ahack and his white whale wrote:“The “glaring inconsistencies” the Talifan complain about have all been addressed in the novels, but they don’t–or don’t want to–read very carefully. The fact that they have not attacked the “glaring inconsistencies” in the original Frank Herbert books with the same vehemence seems a bit of a double standard.””

Well boohoo !
First of all we’ve been reading Dune carefully for years and you sir, write monkey fanfic at best. That defense “they’re not smart enough to understand” is laughable : we have some of the most knowlegeable people online on the subject and the Cast Out can boast having the only english speaking website still active. (Where’s Byron by the way ? Tumbleweeds don’t make the best users you know.. but they have the intellectual level required for your drivel so there you go)

Secondly we did not set any double standards, you did… You did by thinking stealing the franchise from the HLP would give you the credit you think you deserve.
Well I’ve got news for you, it doesn’t work that way The simple fact you seem to really believe your PR BS shows how far away from the truth you are.
Time will tell, and you will be long forgotten when Frank’s work will still shine high above, far from your stinking paws. You have no immortality.

And to finish, Talifan huh ? How inventive ? I’m so hurt by your shimmering wit… What ? You did not come up with it ? Really ?
We are the Iduali, the Jacurutu Cast Out, you have sold Fremen for their water and you wear a collar.

Publish the notes, I dare you.

lotek wrote:Yeah I was a bit angry.

Nekhrun wrote: ↑06 Dec 2011 18:43 Haven't read the link yet, but is this another venue for him to spout his, "No one can be as good as Frank," and "we're the biggest Dune fans," bullshit?