Page 1 of 1

Looking back...

Posted: 15 Mar 2011 23:04
by Nebiros
Looking back over the decades since Frank Herbert first published Dune in 1965, when was the best time to be a Dune fan? I wouldn't know since I have only been a fan since late 2003.

The first decade of the twenty-first century is obviously not the best of times with all this New Dune business. Although the Dune TV miniseries is great. The 90's (including the year 2000) saw the publication first New Dune books but it was not so bad in the sense that the first major lie of Paul not being born on Caladan was not yet written. But the 90's saw the release of the Dune computer games of which I am a big fan as well as some other fanfic which are actually good reads.

Perhaps it was the 80's. Three new Frank Herbert Dune novels, a Dune movie, the first of a lot of fanfic to come and a Frank Herbert Dune Short story. 1984 was for sure a red letter year for all things Dune. The release of Heretics of Dune, the Dune movie and the Dune encyclopedia. Dune fandom was at it's height. But not a very good year for Frank Herbert himself. 1986 however was a sad year when Frank Herbert passed away leaving no way to protect his franchise from a man with a combover and a pig voice.

I don't know much about Dune fans of the 70's though. This decade saw the release of Children of Dune and the first of several Dune merchandise in the form of a board game (to be followed in later years by a card game, a role playing game, computer games, another board game and Dune comic books). Was Frank Herbert more famous in the 70's compared to the mid 60's?

And finally the 60's. Dune was first published in 1965 and Dune Messiah in 1969. I don't know exactly how fast Frank Herbert rose to fame. I know that Dune was actually first released in 1963 in a science fiction magazine. I wonder if there are any pre-1965 dune fans out there.

In my opinion the greatest time to be a fan of Dune was 1984. Maybe this decade will be better than the previous since the New Dune books are declining in popularity.

Re: Looking back...

Posted: 15 Mar 2011 23:08
by zacher2005
Any excuse given for the changing of Paul's birthlace?


Also what was the short story Frank herbert wrote about?

Re: Looking back...

Posted: 16 Mar 2011 00:51
by Ampoliros
Pretty much all roads in nuDune lead back to KJA's claiming that Dune was written by Irulan rather than Frank Herbert, and therefore Dune is the inaccurate text, not the new books.

Re: Looking back...

Posted: 16 Mar 2011 07:39
by zacher2005
Ampoliros wrote:Pretty much all roads in nuDune lead back to KJA's claiming that Dune was written by Irulan rather than Frank Herbert, and therefore Dune is the inaccurate text, not the new books.


wow....just .....wow

Re: Looking back...

Posted: 16 Mar 2011 08:38
by inhuien
zacher2005 wrote:Also what was the short story Frank herbert wrote about?
1885's Eye had a short called The Road to Dune.

Re: Looking back...

Posted: 16 Mar 2011 08:58
by Freakzilla
inhuien wrote:
zacher2005 wrote:Also what was the short story Frank herbert wrote about?
1885's Eye had a short called The Road to Dune.
1995?

Re: Looking back...

Posted: 16 Mar 2011 09:05
by SandChigger
Nebiros wrote:I wonder if there are any pre-1965 dune fans out there.
Yes, I read Dune when I was four. :P

Re: Looking back...

Posted: 16 Mar 2011 09:06
by SandChigger
Freakzilla wrote:
inhuien wrote:
zacher2005 wrote:Also what was the short story Frank herbert wrote about?
1885's Eye had a short called The Road to Dune.
1995?
1685?!

Re: Looking back...

Posted: 16 Mar 2011 10:57
by inhuien
SandChigger wrote:
Freakzilla wrote:
inhuien wrote:
zacher2005 wrote:Also what was the short story Frank herbert wrote about?
1885's Eye had a short called The Road to Dune.
1995?
1685?!
Oh, fir the love of God! Have I no warned you people before no to read the shit I write?

Re: Looking back...

Posted: 16 Mar 2011 11:17
by Freakzilla
I liked being a Dune fan back in 1596, before the dark times, before the empire.

Re: Looking back...

Posted: 16 Mar 2011 11:28
by zacher2005
Freakzilla wrote:I liked being a Dune fan back in 1596, before the dark times, before the empire.

I was a fan of dune in the years 86 BG, bust that. I'll be in Sisterhood of Dune waving in the backround like I am outside of TRL.

Re: Looking back...

Posted: 16 Mar 2011 12:52
by Omphalos
SandChigger wrote:
Nebiros wrote:I wonder if there are any pre-1965 dune fans out there.
Yes, I read Dune when I was four. :P
Three times that year, IIRC.

Re: Looking back...

Posted: 16 Mar 2011 14:47
by merkin muffley
Nebiros wrote: But the 90's saw the release of the Dune computer games of which I am a big fan
I'm a part of that era, first read Dune in the 90's and the computer games made me cream my jeans. Or it might have been all the pot I was smoking while I was playing the video games.
Nebiros wrote:as well as some other fanfic which are actually good reads.
Ah yes, fanfic.

Re: Looking back...

Posted: 16 Mar 2011 14:58
by Eyes High
inhuien wrote:
SandChigger wrote:
Freakzilla wrote:
inhuien wrote:
zacher2005 wrote:Also what was the short story Frank herbert wrote about?
1885's Eye had a short called The Road to Dune.
1995?
1685?!
Oh, fir the love of God! Have I no warned you people before no to read the shit I write?
2525?

Re: Looking back...

Posted: 17 Mar 2011 02:09
by SandChigger
zacher2005 wrote:I was a fan of dune in the years 86 BG, bust that. I'll be in Sisterhood of Dune waving in the backround like I am outside of TRL.
"That new kid is an abomination!" the balding hack said. "His mother deserves a punishment greater than anything in history. Death! It cannot come too quickly for that child or for the one who spawned him!" The asshat pickle fucker pointed a finger at zacher2005. "Get out of my work!"

"TRL?" the BoBo whispered. He snapped his attention back to zacher2005. "By the Great Father!"

"You don't understand, you Herbert doofuss," the hack said. "He's in my book! He's like the one before us, the one who gave us this legacy to rape! He stands in the background of our books like your father! He cannot be there, but he is! Waving his hand at us, not just his middle finger, like your father!"

"What!?" the BoBo said. "What's this nonsense about Frank Herbert, my father?!"

The hack straightened, lowered his pointing hand. "I've said too much!"

Re: Looking back...

Posted: 17 Mar 2011 07:34
by zacher2005
SandChigger wrote:
zacher2005 wrote:I was a fan of dune in the years 86 BG, bust that. I'll be in Sisterhood of Dune waving in the backround like I am outside of TRL.
"That new kid is an abomination!" the balding hack said. "His mother deserves a punishment greater than anything in history. Death! It cannot come too quickly for that child or for the one who spawned him!" The asshat pickle fucker pointed a finger at zacher2005. "Get out of my work!"

"TRL?" the BoBo whispered. He snapped his attention back to zacher2005. "By the Great Father!"

"You don't understand, you Herbert doofuss," the hack said. "He's in my book! He's like the one before us, the one who gave us this legacy to rape! He stands in the background of our books like your father! He cannot be there, but he is! Waving his hand at us, not just his middle finger, like your father!"

"What!?" the BoBo said. "What's this nonsense about Frank Herbert, my father?!"

The hack straightened, lowered his pointing hand. "I've said too much!"



*golf clap

Re: Looking back...

Posted: 17 Mar 2011 08:12
by Tleszer
Nice one, Chig! :lol: